Did Giants Make a Mistake in Keeping Coughlin?

The Sports Prof thinks so. And he lays out a compelling case to support his belief.

I like Coughlin because he brought back Boston College to prominence (or at least the respectability of clawing into the final top 25 of the season). My only defense of Coughlin would be to ask - who else could you get to replace him? Unknowns fail more often than not (much more often than not).

Like I said - the Sports Prof makes some excellent points but sometimes the devil you know is still the best bet.